It’s Marketing, Not Magic

There have been a lot of meaningful examples recently of the ways in which behavioral economics can change consumer behavior. When The Economist offered consumers two subscription levels, the majority of people kept choosing the cheaper, less ideal version. Yet when they introduced a third, more costly option, people suddenly began purchasing the slightly more expensive version that was being originally ignored. As Forbes described it in 2013, “As expected, no one chose the third option, but something magical happened! An overwhelming majority now chose the second option.” That’s right. Magic.

The same article details an extremely popular example many of us know. A group of people were asked to rate bottles of wine. Some were told the wine was very expensive while others were told it was very cheap. Those told the wine was expensive believed it was a better wine—a far better wine—than the version with the less expensive price tag. Magic!

These examples, and many more like them, demonstrate an understanding of a number of different biases people operate under while going through life. The website The Psy-Fi Blog created “The Big List of Behavioral Biases.” The Ambiguity Aversion bias suggests that we hate uncertainty much more than we hate risk. As such, we’re more likely to engage in a riskier behavior we know than one we don’t. As I mentioned in my blog post about the psychology of luck, the Illusion of Control bias is when we make ourselves feel in control of situations over which we have absolutely none.

Unfortunately, with these new biases in hand, many marketers believe they can completely change their consumers. It’s all about the behavior, the environment and the triggers. So we create environments and triggers and attempt to remove obstacles that are along the path to our desired behavior. If we can do these things just right, we can, almost magically, make everyone a loyalist. They will purchase our products in triplicate and do so every Monday at 3:00pm.

So we see websites being built to get consumers to the shopping cart. We see stores redesigned to help them find the most expensive items. For years, grocery stores have put milk at the back of the store so that you have to walk past all of those doughnuts. Sweet, delicious doughnuts.

This, my friends, is behavior change. It is amazing. It is scientific. It is magic.

Or not. And behavior change is a bit of a misleading name because it suggests we, as marketers, can change the behavior of others. Yet we can’t. And if you’ve ever tried to feed a five-year-old green beans, you painfully know this is not true.

We don’t change behavior. We inspire it. We guide it. We make the path to new behavior, and the behavior itself, and the reward of that behavior, as positive as possible (or as least negative as possible). It isn’t a magic wand. It’s empathy. It’s why in every model of behavior change you might find (consider BJ Fogg‘s model), you will see that there must be some level of motivation. In order for us to identify that motivation or help provide that motivation, we have to have a deeper understanding of the human truth. Then we can change human behavior.

So put away your psychology wands and get to work listening to your customer. Once you get to know them, you’ll know exactly how to inspire them.

Share Knowledge

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Continue Learning

Related Resources

Emotions Rule the Roost

The power of any brand is, simply, how your association with it makes you feel. You might say you have rational reasons for choosing one brand over another, but even...

How to Win Customers—and Friends

It is hard for me to imagine managing a brand with any other intent than winning customers the way we win friends. Would you invite me to your home and make me wait at the front door until you got around to answering it? Would you not take my coat or leave me sitting in the living room by myself for half an hour? Would you serve me a warm martini with a hair in it? Would you leave me sitting at the dining room table by myself while you got on the phone to talk to your cousin in Oshkosh? If this sounds like a gruesome picture, compare it to the way some brands appear to operate.

Creating the Magic of a Brand

In the context of a life being lived with all its doubt and certainty, happiness and sadness, it might seem trivial to talk about what part brands play in these engrossing privacies. But we must look there because it's around the doubt and certainty, and within the happiness and sadness, that brand stories must truly reside. And when we think about how we can attract extremely distracted people to our sainted product, we have to think about how it can contribute to their enchanting dramas, how it might find a place within their deeply personal sense of identity, how it can make the journey of their lives easier, better, happier, or somehow more fulfilling.

Webinar | 11/04/21

The Truth About Trust: Exploring What Trust Means to Brands

444 N. Michigan Avenue Suite 3100, Chicago, IL 60611